Published: 08/13/2024
Virtually everyone is familiar with fluoride toothpaste. After all, fluoride has been considered the gold standard in dental care for decades. It has been hailed as the most effective way to prevent cavities and thus has widely been recommended by dentists. However, a new contender has recently emerged in the world of oral health. Hydroxyapatite is a compound touted as a more natural alternative. It’s gaining popularity as a potential alternative for remineralizing teeth. But in the debate between fluoride vs. hydroxyapatite, how do the two compare? And is it time to consider making the switch?
What Is Fluoride?
Fluoride is a mineral found in water, soil, and even some foods. You can find various forms of fluoride in toothpaste—typically sodium fluoride, stannous fluoride, or mono-fluorophosphate. Its ability to help prevent tooth decay has been extensively studied over the past few decades. And it’s widely accepted by dental professionals as an essential tool for oral care.
Its primary function is to strengthen tooth enamel so it’s more resistant to acid attacks from bacteria in the mouth. Fluoride works by promoting the remineralization process, where minerals like calcium and phosphate are redeposited into tooth enamel after being lost due to acid exposure. It also helps fight the growth of harmful oral bacteria to help decrease the risk of cavities.
Floride pros:
- Proven effectiveness: with decades of research to support fluoride’s role in preventing cavities and strengthening enamel, it’s a tried and trusted ingredient for oral health.
- Widely available: you don’t need to go looking for a toothpaste that contains fluoride. Most commercially available toothpastes found at your local market contain fluoride.
- Affordable: Fluoride toothpastes are generally less expensive than specialty toothpaste options like those that contain hydroxyapatite.
Floride Cons:
- Risks if overexposed: Excessive fluoride exposure, especially in children, can lead to fluorosis, which causes the teeth to discolor.
- Sensitivity: Some people also find some types of fluoride toothpaste increase tooth sensitivity.
- Nutrient interactions: Fluoride may negatively impact the activity of certain nutrients in the body. For example, high fluoride exposure (through drinking water, high amounts in the local soil, combined with the use of fluoride products) may interact with iodine in the body. Iodine is essential for thyroid function.
- Controversial for some: Despite its long-standing and widespread use, there’s an ongoing debate concerning the potential health risks of fluoride among some groups.
What Is Hydroxyapatite?
Hydroxyapatite, on the other hand, is a naturally occurring form of calcium found in our bones and teeth. It makes up around 97% of tooth enamel and 70% of dentin (the layer just beneath the enamel), so it mimics the natural mineral structure of your teeth.
Unlike fluoride, which strengthens teeth by promoting the natural remineralization process, hydroxyapatite directly integrates with the enamel. When people brush with toothpaste that contains hydroxyapatite, it appears to work by filling in the microscopic gaps and scratches in the enamel. By directly integrating with the enamel and remineralizing and repairing the surface of teeth, it helps restore the tooth structure and reduces sensitivity.
When choosing a hydroxyapatite toothpaste, though, it’s important to consider the type of hydroxyapatite used, as this can impact how effective it is. The most common forms found in dental products are nano-hydroxyapatite and microcrystalline hydroxyapatite.
Nano-hydroxyapatite has smaller particles, allowing it to more effectively penetrate the tiny pores and cracks in the enamel, making it particularly beneficial for repairing and strengthening teeth.
Microcrystalline hydroxyapatite, on the other hand, is closer to the natural size found in human teeth and bones. It tends to be favored by folks seeking a product that mimics the body’s natural composition.
Both forms appear to be effective. However, nano-hydroxyapatite is often highlighted for its superior remineralizing capabilities.
Hydroxyapatite Pros:
- Natural: Hydroxyapatite is a biocompatible, naturally occurring substance already found in the human body, including a large percentage of tooth enamel.
- Repair: By filling in micro-cracks and scratches, hydroxyapatite helps restore the natural structure of tooth enamel.
- Reduced sensitivity: Many users report a reduction in tooth sensitivity when using the product.
- Whitening: Hydroxyapatite is also a natural tooth whitener, so it may lead to a brighter smile.
Hydroxyapatite Cons:
- Harder to find: Because hydroxyapatite toothpaste is fairly new, it may be harder to find, especially if you tend to only shop at your local market.
- Higher cost: Again, it’s a new product, so it’s often a bit (or sometimes a lot) more expensive than traditional toothpaste made with fluoride.
- Fewer studies: Make no mistake, the early research is promising. However, unlike fluoride, you won’t find decades of research supporting the effectiveness of the compound.
Which Is More Effective? Fluoride vs. Hydroxyapatite
Both fluoride and hydroxyapatite are effective in their own ways, but they work differently to achieve the same goals: stronger, healthier teeth. Fluoride has a long track record of success in preventing cavities and is widely endorsed by dental professionals. Hydroxyapatite, while newer to the market, has shown highly promising results in clinical studies, especially when it comes to its ability to repair enamel and reduce tooth sensitivity.
Should You Switch?
The choice between fluoride vs. hydroxyapatite often comes down to personal preference, dental needs, and lifestyle choices. For example, for people seeking a more natural product, hydroxyapatite toothpaste may be more appealing. Especially if you have concerns about overexposure to fluoride or are looking for a toothpaste that can help repair enamel, reduce tooth sensitivity, or has whitening properties, hydroxyapatite may be worth considering.
However, before you make any changes to your oral healthcare routine, remember to consult with your trusted dentist. They can provide personalized advice based on your dental health and help you choose the best toothpaste for you.
Whether you stick with fluoride or opt for hydroxyapatite, the key is to maintain consistent oral hygiene practices, including brushing your teeth twice daily, flossing consistently, and visiting your dentist regularly.
In the end, both hydroxyapatite and fluoride toothpaste offer unique benefits, and the best choice is one that aligns with your dental health goals, lifestyle, and perhaps availability.
Talk to Us About an Appointment